This One Word Could Be The Key to a Successful New Years Resolution

A man sitting in bed thoughtfully journaling, representing the practice of mindful reflection and cognitive shifts in goal setting.

Every January, something hopeful happens. People across Northeast Ohio (and everywhere else) wake up on the first and decide this year is going to be different. New goals. Fresh start. Real commitment.

And then, somewhere around the third week of January, things get quiet. The gym empties out. The journals stop. The motivation that felt so real on January 1st starts to feel like someone else’s idea.

You’re not alone in this, and you’re not weak. There’s actually a reason it keeps happening. And it comes down to one three-letter word.

Why Do So Few People Actually Keep Their Resolutions?

Making a New Year’s resolution is one of the oldest human traditions we have. It dates back to ancient Babylon, where people made promises to their gods at the start of each year, pledging to return borrowed items and pay off debts. Fast forward a few thousand years, and we’re still doing it, though now our goals tend to look more like “lose 20 pounds” or “stop scrolling at midnight.”

The research on resolution success rates is genuinely sobering. According to Forbes, roughly 40% of Americans make New Year’s resolutions each year. Of those, only about 8% actually follow through. We’ve been doing this long enough that there’s no shortage of advice on how to do it better. The American Psychological Association recommends keeping resolutions specific and simple, enlisting support from others, and breaking goals into measurable steps.

Good advice. And still, most resolutions don’t make it to February.

So what’s getting in the way?

What Does the Word “But” Have to Do With It?

I want you to pay attention to the next thought you have about a goal. Really listen to the structure of it.

“I want to exercise more, but I’m too tired after work.” “I want to eat better, but healthy food is expensive.” “I want to call my mom more, but I never know what to say.”

That word right in the middle? That’s where the resolution dies.

Norman Vincent Peale wrote in “The Power of Positive Thinking” that we must plant seeds of expectation in our minds and cultivate thoughts that anticipate achievement. The moment we use “but,” we do the opposite. We give ourselves a built-in exit. We frame the obstacle as bigger than the goal, and our brain takes the hint.

The Cleveland Clinic reports that we have an average of 60,000 thoughts per day, and about 95% of them are the same thoughts repeated from the day before. Of those habitual thoughts, roughly 80% skew negative. That’s a lot of internal resistance working against you before you’ve even laced up your shoes.

Is There a Simple Shift That Can Actually Help?

Yes. And it won’t cost you anything.

Swap “but” for “and.”

That’s it. One word. Try it with the same sentences:

“I want to exercise more, and I’m going to take a 10-minute walk after dinner to start.”

“I want to eat better, and I’m going to batch-cook on Sundays so healthy food is actually in my fridge.”

“I want to call my mom more, and I’m going to put a reminder on my calendar for Sunday mornings.”

Notice what changed. The obstacle is still there. The challenge didn’t disappear. But now the sentence doesn’t stop at the wall. It keeps going. It implies action. It assumes you’ll find a way.

That shift from “I can’t” to “I will” is not just motivational. There’s real psychology behind it.

What Does Research Say About Positive Thinking and Goal Achievement?

Researcher Barbara Fredrickson developed what she calls the Broaden and Build theory. The basic idea is this: positive emotions don’t just feel good, they actually expand your thinking. When you’re feeling open and capable, you see more options. You’re more creative about problem-solving. You’re more likely to take the next step.

Negative framing does the opposite. When you tell yourself “I want to do X, but I can’t because Y,” your brain narrows around the obstacle. The goal starts to feel impossible before you’ve really tried.

Changing “but” to “and” is a small but meaningful way to shift the emotional register of your thoughts. You’re not pretending the obstacle isn’t there. You’re refusing to let it be the end of the sentence.

In my experience working with clients at Lamplight, I’ve seen this pattern show up again and again. People come in describing their goals almost apologetically. “I want to feel better, but I’ve tried before and it didn’t work.” The goal is real. The motivation is real. But the language they’re using is already building a case for failure.

Part of what we do in therapy is help people hear their own thoughts more clearly and start to challenge the ones that aren’t serving them. If you’re curious about how that process works, our post on understanding anxiety touches on how thought patterns connect to the way we feel and behave every day.

How Can You Put This Into Practice Starting Now?

Here’s a simple exercise to try this week.

Write down your top resolution or goal. Then write the “but” version of it, the way your brain usually frames it when things get hard. Read it out loud. Notice how it feels in your body.

Now rewrite it with “and.” Make the second half of the sentence a specific, doable action. Something small enough that you could actually do it today.

The goal isn’t to be blindly optimistic. It’s to keep the sentence moving forward instead of stopping at the obstacle.

Research from the American Psychological Association also supports building small, measurable steps into your goals rather than relying on willpower alone. Willpower is a depleting resource. Structure and habit are not.

If you’re working on a goal that touches something deeper, like managing anxiety, improving your relationships, or getting unstuck from patterns that keep repeating, therapy can be a meaningful part of that process. Not because you need fixing, but because having a trained person in your corner changes the math. You can read more about what to look for in that process in our guide on finding the right therapist.

What If the Goal Feels Too Big to Start?

That’s the most common sticking point, and it’s worth naming directly.

Big goals feel overwhelming because we look at the whole thing at once. You don’t have to. You just have to find the next “and.”

“I want to feel less anxious, and I’m going to try one breathing exercise this week.”

“I want to improve my marriage, and we’re going to have dinner together without phones on Friday.”

“I want to feel more like myself, and I’m going to look into what therapy actually involves.”

That last one is a real step. The American Psychological Association offers a solid overview of how to approach goal setting with self-compassion and realistic expectations if you want to explore the research further.

Here in Northeast Ohio, we have a particular kind of resilience. People here don’t quit easily. But sometimes we carry that grit in the wrong direction, grinding through the same patterns year after year instead of trying something different. Changing one word is something different. It’s small enough to do today. And small enough is where most real change actually starts.

So as you think about what you want this year, try this: resolve to keep the sentence going. Not “I want to, but…” and stop there. “I want to, and here’s what I’m going to do.”

That “and” is where your resolution actually begins.

 

If any of this resonates and you’re not sure where to start, reach out to our team at Lamplight. We’ll help you figure out the right fit. Contact us here.

 
Scroll to Top